Investment Property Loans in Durango, CO

Rental property loans from a local broker

Buying a rental in Durango, adding a duplex to your portfolio, or turning a long-held property into cash for the next one? I’m Peter Pritchard, a Durango mortgage broker for 28 years, and I help investors finance 1-4 unit rental properties across Durango, Bayfield and La Plata County.

Durango-specific things investors should plan for

Wood-sided rental house with a front porch
Ranch house below the mountains in northern Colorado

What to expect with a rental property loan

Lenders view rental properties as higher risk than a home you live in, so investment loans generally come with a larger down payment, somewhat higher pricing and more reserve requirements than a primary residence. Exact requirements vary by lender, property type and your overall financial picture. I’ll lay out the real numbers for your situation before you write an offer.

Planning to live in one unit of a duplex, triplex or fourplex? Owner-occupied 2-4 unit purchases can qualify for primary-residence financing, which often means a smaller down payment. Ask me whether that fits your plans.

Using the property partly yourself and renting it occasionally? That may be a second home loan instead. The category matters, and I’ll help you get it right from the start.

Investment property loans I can shop for you

  • Conventional investment property loans for single-family homes, condos and townhomes you plan to rent
  • 2-4 unit properties (duplexes, triplexes and fourplexes), whether you live in one unit or rent all of them
  • Cash-out refinances on rentals you already own, to fund repairs or your next purchase
  • Loans for self-employed investors who need flexible income documentation
  • Jumbo financing for higher-priced properties above the conforming limit

As a broker, I compare multiple lenders instead of offering one bank’s products, so you can see more than one option side by side.

Talk to a local investment property lender

Call or text me at 970-828-1610, visit our office at 1099 Main Avenue, Suite 305 in Durango, or send me a message. I’ll run the numbers honestly, including whether the property cash-flows after the mortgage.

Not sure where to start? See how I compare mortgage lenders in Durango for you.

Customer Love

Wes Weichert

April 28, 2026
Peter was fantastic to work with and made the home buying process far less stressful than I expected. He was extremely responsive, always took the time to explain things clearly, and kept everything moving forward. As a first-time homebuyer I really appreciated how patient and knowledgeable he was. Highly recommend working with him.

Michelle Blades

April 18, 2026
Our overall experience was incredible. Could not have asked for a better lender (Peter). From start to finish it took 10 days. Thank you!!

Deborah Moore

April 10, 2026
Peter went above and beyond what I thought was gonna happen. In the past it was always so hard to get in touch with the finance people. He was always available no matter week day or weekend and always took the time to explain everything, and being 78 years old that was very much appreciated. I would highly recommend Peter Pritchard for anyone buying a house.

Joseph Williams

November 1, 2025
Peter was the best! Quick and painless.

Dianne Ray

October 25, 2025
Peter was great to work with. He kept things moving and always kept us informed. He worked with our schedule and always made it work. We would definitely work with Peter again!

Karen Boush

October 11, 2025
I feel incredibly fortunate to have worked with Peter Pritchard at Animas Mountain Mortgage to finance my new home in La Plata County. When I started looking for a new home, I knew very little about the process of taking out a mortgage, but Peter helped me evaluate my options and guided me through the process so that my loan was competitive and right for my financial situation. He's extremely knowledgeable, responsive, and patient, and I highly recommend him as someone you can trust and count on to help you as he helped me!

Vaughn Johnson

August 27, 2025
First rate experience with friendly communication, prompt and accurate responses to questions, and extra mile patience. Greatly appreciate the opportunity to work with Peter and Animas Mountain Mortage!

Matthew Weideman

August 1, 2025
Peter worked with us every step of the way and was incredibly helpful! Thanks for helping us get a great house!

Emily Grant

July 8, 2025
As a realtor, I’ve worked with many lenders, and Peter consistently delivers. He’s responsive, knowledgeable, and truly invested in helping my clients reach their financing goals. Always a smooth process from pre-approval to closing. Highly recommend!

Brigitte Holiday

June 17, 2025
I had a wonderful experience working with Peter at Animas Mortgage. From our very first meeting, he was professional, helpful, and genuinely kind. He kept in touch with me throughout the entire process and made it easy to reach him in multiple ways. Peter’s knowledge and guidance helped me make the best decisions for my situation. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a trustworthy and supportive mortgage broker.

Find The Right Home For Your Budget