Offer Comparison Calculator

Got more than one offer? Put up to three side by side and see the seller’s estimated net for each, what each nets if the appraisal comes in low, and the terms that matter beyond the price.

Offer comparison calculator

Which offer nets the seller the most?

For listing agents: put up to three offers side by side and see the seller’s estimated net for each, plus what happens if the appraisal comes in low.

The seller’s costs (same for every offer)
As a share of the price
Title policy, closing fee, prorations, HOA transfer
Shows each financed offer at that value
Offer A
Cash the buyer will add if the appraisal is low
Offer B (optional)
Cash the buyer will add if the appraisal is low
Offer C (optional)
Cash the buyer will add if the appraisal is low

Net to seller is an estimate before property tax and HOA prorations. Sharing creates a link with the numbers you entered, so someone else can open the same results. Nothing you enter is saved on this site. These are estimates from the numbers you enter, not a loan offer or a rate quote. Your actual rate, payment and costs depend on your credit, the loan program and the property.

How the net to the seller is figured

For each offer, the calculator starts with the offer price and subtracts:

  • any seller credit to the buyer
  • the buyer’s agent fee, if the buyer asks the seller to pay it
  • the listing fee
  • other selling costs, like the title policy, closing fee and HOA transfer
  • the mortgage payoff

The seller’s costs you enter once apply to every offer, so the comparison is apples to apples. Property tax and HOA prorations aren’t counted, since they’re about the same whichever offer the seller takes.

What if the appraisal comes in low?

Enter a possible appraised value to see each financed offer at that number. A buyer with a loan has to cover any gap between the price and the appraisal in cash, up to the appraisal gap coverage written into the offer. Past that, the price usually gets renegotiated. A cash offer doesn’t need an appraisal, so its price stays the same.

Look past the highest number

The biggest net isn’t always the strongest offer. The calculator lines up the terms next to the numbers:

  • Earnest money: how much the buyer has at stake.
  • Days to close: when the seller gets paid.
  • Appraisal gap coverage: how much a low appraisal would cost the seller.
  • Home sale contingency: whether the buyer has to sell a home first.

Ask each buyer’s lender what has been reviewed so far: credit, income and assets, or a full underwriting approval. That says more about closing on time than the loan type does.

For listing agents

Run the offers before you sit down with your seller. Then click Print for a clean summary, or Email these results to send it to the seller. Add your own email address and replies come to you.

Negotiating a seller credit? The cash to close and seller credit calculator shows the most a seller can pay for each loan type. More tools are on the For Agents page and the calculators page. Questions about the financing in an offer? Call or text me at 970-828-1610.

Questions about comparing offers

How is net to seller calculated?

Offer price minus the seller credit, any buyer’s agent fee the seller pays, the listing fee, other selling costs and the mortgage payoff. It’s an estimate before property tax and HOA prorations.

What is appraisal gap coverage?

It’s a promise in the offer that the buyer will bring extra cash if the home appraises for less than the price, up to a set amount. It protects the seller’s price if the appraisal comes in low.

Is a cash offer always better?

Not always. A cash offer skips the appraisal and often closes faster, but a financed offer at a higher price can still net the seller more. Compare the net and the terms side by side.

Does the loan type matter?

Less than how far along the buyer’s approval is. A buyer whose credit, income and assets have already been reviewed by the lender is in a stronger position than one with only a quick pre-qualification, whatever the loan type.